Notebook
Theme or custom website: when each one pays off
A bought theme is quick and cheap, a custom website grows with the company. When a theme is enough, when custom pays off and what to watch out for.
A new website can go two ways: buy a ready-made theme and fill it with content, or have a custom site built. A theme costs a fraction of the price and is ready fast. A custom site costs more and takes longer. Which one pays off depends on what the site should do in two or three years.
What a theme is
A theme is a ready-made design with prepared blocks, sold to thousands of companies at once. It has to do everything for everyone: a restaurant, a law firm and an e-shop. So it carries a lot of features, settings and code.
When it is enough:
- you need a simple presentation with a few pages,
- the budget is small and the site needs to be ready fast,
- your content fits what the theme offers.
What to watch out for:
- Speed. A theme loads code for features you do not use. You can usually tell on mobile.
- Content bends to fit the blocks. Instead of the site speaking for the company, it speaks for the theme.
- Changes cost more than they seem. Changing something the theme author did not plan for often means fighting their code.
- The same look as your competitors. Popular themes are on hundreds of sites.
What a custom website is
A custom site starts from the content. First it is clear what the site should do and for whom, then the structure and design are created, and only then is it built. It contains only what it actually needs.
When it pays off:
- the site should bring in enquiries, not just exist,
- the company has several services, languages or content types (references, branches, careers),
- content will be changed by people without technical skills, and they must not break anything,
- speed and search rankings matter.
What to watch out for:
- Price and timeline. A custom site is an investment. Ask for a fixed price, not an hourly rate.
- Who will run it. A well-built site can be managed without a developer. A badly built one depends on one person.
The difference in managing content
With a theme, content is usually assembled in a page builder: you drag blocks, change colours and spacing. It is flexible, but the layout breaks easily, and after six months every page looks different.
With a custom site, content goes into fields: heading, text, price, opening hours. It always looks the same, even when five different people enter it.
How to decide
- What should the site do? If it is a business card, a theme is enough. If it should sell, custom pays off.
- Will it grow? The more content and features are added, the more the theme gets in the way.
- What does a year with a theme cost? Count the changes, extra plugins and time spent fighting the editor.
A theme is a good start. A custom website is a good foundation. If you know the site should bring in work for years, it pays to start on a solid foundation.